Comparing Gas vs. Electric Water Heaters: Pros, Cons & Costs

As the weather starts to cool in Saskatoon, reliable hot water becomes even more essential. If your water heater is showing its age or becoming less efficient, you might be weighing the benefits of a gas versus an electric replacement. At Excelsior Mechanical Ltd, we know that choosing the right water heater affects your monthly expenses, home comfort, and the dependability of your daily routine. Here’s an in-depth look at the advantages, drawbacks, and ongoing costs of gas and electric water heaters—tailored for homes in Saskatoon, Warman, and Martensville.


Understanding Gas & Electric Water Heaters


A water heater warms your home's water supply using either natural gas or electricity. Each type features unique installation requirements, operating costs, and maintenance demands. The best option for your household depends on your needs, home infrastructure, and long-term goals.


Gas Water Heaters: Power and Efficiency for Busy Households


Pros:

- Rapid Heating: Gas water heaters heat water quicker than most electric models, which is a plus for families or homes with heavy usage.

- Lower Energy Bills: In Saskatchewan, natural gas is typically more affordable than electricity by the unit, translating to lower running costs over time.

- Not Dependent on Power: In the event of a power outage, gas water heaters can continue working, which offers peace of mind during periods of heavy weather.


Cons:

- Higher Installation Expense: Gas water heaters require a gas line, proper venting, and compliance with building codes, making installation costlier.

- Regular Maintenance Needed: Gas systems need annual safety and performance checks to guard against leaks and ensure safe operation.

- Size and Ventilation: These units generally take up more space and require proper venting to the outdoors.


Electric Water Heaters: Simplicity and Flexibility


Pros:

- Lower Initial Cost: Electric water heaters are typically less expensive to purchase and install, ideal for those seeking a quick upgrade.

- Easier Installation: Without the need for venting or gas connections, electric models can fit into smaller spaces and are less disruptive to install.

- Less Maintenance: There are fewer parts that require routine service, so electric heaters generally need less professional maintenance.


Cons:

- Higher Operation Costs: With electricity rates in Saskatchewan, electric heaters tend to cost more to run compared to their gas counterparts.

- Slower Heating Recovery: Electric units typically take longer to reheat water after heavy usage, which can matter for larger families.

- Dependence on Power: These units won’t function if your home loses electricity.


Comparing Costs: Investment and Monthly Savings


Homeowners often prioritize the overall cost when deciding on a new water heater. Here’s an overview:

- Installation Costs: Expect to pay about $1,000–$1,500 for a gas unit, versus $700–$1,000 for an electric model, including installation.

- Utility Bills: With current rates, gas heaters can be 25–40% less expensive to run monthly than electric.

- Servicing: Gas units need yearly professional servicing, while electric heaters may go years without complex maintenance.


Environmental Impact


If sustainability is important to your household, consider the environmental footprint of each type. Electric heaters can run on renewable power, making them a greener choice if you source electricity from renewables. While they are energy-efficient, gas heaters rely on natural gas, which emits greenhouse gasses.


Making the Right Choice for Your Home


Selecting the right water heater depends on your family’s size, water use, budget, and the infrastructure in your home. For busy, high-demand households, gas offers rapid recovery and lower operating expenses. If your home is smaller, or if your priority is a lower upfront investment and simpler installation, electric might be right for you. Those who want to ensure hot water during power outages will also appreciate the reliability of gas systems.


Ready for an Upgrade? Trust Excelsior Mechanical for Expert Advice and Installation


Don’t let an outdated or unreliable water heater disrupt your comfort at home. Excelsior Mechanical Ltd is your local expert for gas and electric water heater services in Saskatoon, Warman, and Martensville. Our experienced team will help you evaluate your options for best performance, efficiency, and value.


Contact Excelsior Mechanical Ltd to schedule your in-home water heater consultation. We’ll answer your questions, recommend the right solution, and provide seamless installation and ongoing maintenance. Visit www.excelsiormechanical.com or give us a call today.


Enjoy dependable hot water and energy savings, season after season, with Excelsior Mechanical—the trusted choice for water heater solutions in the Saskatoon area!


Share This Blog

A concrete platform with pipes and a box on it
October 15, 2025
Explore the essential steps for successful sump pump installations that protect your home.
A basement with a furnace , water heater , and air conditioner.
October 7, 2025
See how to determine when replacing your furnace is better than continuous repairs for your property.
A man is working on a heating system in a home.
September 24, 2025
Recognize critical situations and get guidance on when immediate HVAC repair is crucial.
A heater is hanging from the ceiling next to a pipe.
September 16, 2025
Get practical tips on maintaining unit heaters for dependable garage warmth throughout the year.
Smiling plumber in blue overalls by a water heater, taking notes.
September 13, 2025
Discover the benefits of energy-efficient hot water tanks and how to choose the right one for your Saskatoon home.
A man wearing a mask is installing a water heater.
September 10, 2025
Understand the step-by-step process and benefits of a thorough boiler system inspection.
Basement with furnace, water heater, electrical panel, pipes, and ducts against white cinder block walls.
September 6, 2025
Is your furnace ready for winter? Learn the signs it needs replacement and ensure your home's comfort with Excelsior Mechanical.
A small device is sitting on top of a white air purifier.
September 2, 2025
Uncover smart HVAC solutions to enhance indoor air quality and create a healthier living environment.
August 27, 2025
As the summer winds down in August and you prepare for the cooler months ahead in Saskatoon, Warman, and Martensville, ensuring your home’s hot water tank is operating efficiently is more important than ever. Hot water tanks are the backbone of comfortable living—providing reliable hot showers, clean dishes, and peace of mind. But what should you do when problems arise? Understanding common hot water tank issues—and how to troubleshoot them—can help you avoid cold showers, water damage, or even costly emergency repairs. In this guide, Excelsior Mechanical Ltd breaks down frequent problems, offers troubleshooting tips, and explains when to call your trusted local HVAC experts. No Hot Water? Start Here If you turn on the tap and find only cold water, the issue may be simpler than you think. For electric hot water tanks, begin by checking the circuit breaker to ensure it hasn’t tripped. For gas models, confirm that the pilot light is lit—if not, follow the manufacturer’s guidelines for safe relighting. Sometimes, the thermostat may have been accidentally adjusted, so verify the temperature setting. If your tank is still not producing hot water after these basic checks, a faulty heating element, thermostat, or thermocouple could be the culprit. This is the point at which calling a professional for hot water tank repairs is the safest and most efficient route. Inconsistent or Lukewarm Water? Adjust and Inspect When your hot water is lukewarm instead of piping hot, mineral sediment buildup can be to blame—a common issue during and after the busy summer months. Sediment accumulates at the bottom of the tank and insulates water from the heating element, reducing efficiency. Draining and flushing your tank in August, before fall arrives, is a good maintenance practice. If you notice the problem persists, your tank’s dip tube (which brings cold water to the bottom of the tank to be heated) may be cracked or deteriorated, requiring professional replacement. Low Hot Water Pressure—Check the Valves and Pipes A sudden drop in hot water pressure throughout your home can be concerning. The most common causes in Saskatoon area homes are partially closed shut-off valves, clogged pipes, or mineral scale in the tank and plumbing system. Start by checking and fully opening the hot water shut-off valve near your tank. If that’s not the issue, cleaning aerators in your taps and showerheads can remove minor debris. For persistent pressure drops or signs of corrosion, it’s best to consult with your local plumbing experts at Excelsior Mechanical Ltd for a thorough inspection and solution. Strange Noises from the Hot Water Tank Popping or rumbling sounds coming from your hot water tank are signs that sediment has settled and is interacting with the tank’s heating elements. In August, as water usage shifts with the season, these noises often become more noticeable. Flushing the tank can resolve minor sediment buildups, but recurring noises could indicate that your tank is aging, or that an element is overheating—both of which require professional assessment. Leaking or Pooling Water—Act Immediately If you notice water pooling around your hot water tank, inspect connections, temperature-pressure relief valves, and pipes for visible signs of leakage. Occasionally, leaks stem from loose fittings and can be resolved by tightening connections. However, a leaking tank body—or any significant puddling—signals a serious problem and might require a tank replacement. Prompt action is crucial to prevent water damage and potential mold growth, especially as the weather begins to cool and windows close more frequently. When to Call Your Saskatoon Hot Water Tank Pros While simple issues like tripped breakers, pilot lights, or basic thermostat adjustments can be handled by homeowners, many hot water tank repairs and maintenance steps are best left to professionals. Licensed technicians from Excelsior Mechanical Ltd have the expertise and tools to safely flush tanks, replace faulty components, inspect for efficiency, and ensure compliance with all local codes and safety regulations. With decades of experience serving Saskatoon, Warman, and Martensville, our team is committed to delivering efficient, lasting, and reliable hot water solutions for your home. Stay Warm and Worry-Free This Fall—Book Your Hot Water Tank Service! August is the perfect time to troubleshoot, repair, or maintain your hot water tank before the busy fall season arrives. Don’t wait for a breakdown or cold water surprise— contact Excelsior Mechanical Ltd today for expert hot water tank inspections, maintenance, and repairs in Saskatoon, Warman, and Martensville. Visit www.excelsiormechanical.com or give us a call to schedule your appointment and keep your home comfortable, energy-efficient, and ready for the colder months ahead. Your neighbourhood experts are here to help—stay warm, stay comfortable, and trust Excelsior Mechanical with all your hot water needs!
A man is working on a heating system in a basement.
August 19, 2025
Explore how scheduled furnace maintenance improves efficiency, reliability, and air quality in your home.